Current:Home > MyWhat are the rules of war? And how do they apply to Israel's actions in Gaza? -ProgressCapital
What are the rules of war? And how do they apply to Israel's actions in Gaza?
View
Date:2025-04-27 21:56:33
Six days after a brutal attack by armed Hamas militants on Israeli civilians, Israel ordered an evacuation of more than 1 million Palestinians in northern Gaza ahead of what could be an unprecedented ground offensive there against Hamas.
"We are going to destroy Hamas infrastructures, Hamas headquarters, Hamas military," vowed Israeli Defense Minister Yoav Gallant as airstrikes were underway.
The U.S. and other nations have repeatedly warned Israel to follow the "rules of war."
But what are they? And will they prevent civilians from being hurt?
Here's what to know about international humanitarian laws and how they might apply in the Israeli-Hamas conflict in Gaza.
MORE: Israel-Gaza live updates: Biden worried about 'death' in potential ground invasion
Is Israel bound by the rules of war?
Yes.
Israel has promised to abide by international humanitarian law including those under the Geneva Convention that seeks to minimize the impact on civilians, provide aid to the wounded on the battlefield, and not to mistreat prisoners of war.
In general, the U.S. military and Israeli Defense Force also rely on similar rules of engagement in military operations.
Israel insists it follows the rules of war and always has.
But there is disagreement by international groups about exactly what qualifies as a violation in a country's quest to defend itself against terror attacks, as well as whether Israel could be prosecuted through the International Criminal Court -- an entity Israel doesn't recognize.
Officials at the United Nations and European Union have accused Israel of already violating its promise not to harm civilians by cutting water and electricity to all of Gaza residents, including to hospitals. They also say it's impossible to ensure the safety of so many civilians by giving only 24 hours to evacuate to avoid the fighting.
Palestinian health authorities estimate 1,799 civilians have been killed in Israeli airstrikes, including 583 children, following Hamas' attacks that have killed at least 1,300 Israelis.
MORE: 'Extremely difficult': What would be Israel's objectives in an offensive into Gaza?
Ravina Shamdasani, spokesperson for the Office of the U.N. High Commissioner for Human rights, said Hamas' brutality doesn't "liberate" Israel from adhering to international humanitarian laws.
"It is absolutely crucial that Israeli leaders and global leaders make it unambiguously clear that international humanitarian law is an obligation. It is not optional, and that military operations must be conducted in full compliance with international law," she said.
President Joe Biden said he delivered that message directly to Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu this week, later telling reporters "that it is really important that Israel, with all the anger and frustration … they operate by the rules of war."
"And there are rules of war," Biden added.
MORE: Israel tells more than 1 million Gazans to flee south to avoid fighting, but is that even possible?
How would the rules apply in this conflict? Would civilians be spared?
Avoiding harm to civilians though can fall into a gray area, particularly when it comes to a massive ground operation unfolding on a remarkably narrow strip of land. Gaza is among the most populated areas on Earth, roughly 7.5 miles at its widest and 25 miles long with some 2 million inhabitants.
Eric Oehlerich, a retired Navy SEAL and ABC News contributor, said that even with sophisticated weaponry, such an operation would be extraordinarily difficult to carry out with no civilians harmed.
"There isn't a force in the world that can deal with 40,000 (enemy) soldiers interspersed with civilians in that densely populated area" and have "zero" civilian deaths, said Oehlerich.
"It's impossible," he added.
One question will be what constitutes a valid military target, said Mick Mulroy, a former deputy assistant secretary of defense for the Middle East and retired CIA paramilitary operations officer.
MORE: Doctors say Gaza hospital situation dire
Israel says that Hamas -- which doesn't abide by humanitarian laws in its deliberate attack on civilians last week -- uses Palestinian civilians and hospitals as shields.
"If Hamas holds up in a building -- whether it's a hospital or mosque -- it becomes a valid military target," said Mulroy, also an ABC contributor. "That said, every reasonable step should be taken to eliminate or reduce civilian casualties (and) has to be done."
MORE: Biden speaks with families of missing Americans, says they're going through 'agony'
What does all this mean for hostages held by Hamas and US citizens inside Gaza?
Oehlerich, who has participated in military operations to free hostages, said getting those hostages out using military force will also be extraordinarily tough. That's because Hamas will likely have gone to great lengths to hide the hostages, including possibly rigging secret tunnels or even the hostages themselves with explosives.
MORE: How to help victims of the deadly and distructive Israel-Gaza conflict
Oehlerich said success is more likely to come through backchannel negotiations with countries like Egypt and Qatar.
Israeli officials say its special operations forces have been operating inside Gaza in past days trying to locate hostages. The US is also working the Red Cross and the UN to establish "safe zones" for foreign nationals to leave, including Americans located within Palestine, according to a senior State Department official.
Beyond that, questions remain on how many innocent people will be hurt or killed inside Gaza. When asked by a reporter Friday what worries him most about the Israeli ground invasion, Biden had a one-word answer.
"Death," he said.
ABC News' Shannon Crawford, William Gretsky and Mary Bruce contributed to this report.
veryGood! (3)
Related
- Jamaica's Kishane Thompson more motivated after thrilling 100m finish against Noah Lyles
- Gov. DeSantis signs bill requiring teaching of history of communism in Florida schools
- New York competition, smoking, internet betting concerns roil US northeast’s gambling market
- New Hampshire man who brought decades-old youth center abuse scandal to light testifies at trial
- 3 years after the NFL added a 17th game, the push for an 18th gets stronger
- Who owns businesses in California? A lawmaker wants the public to know
- Kentucky spokeswoman: School is ‘distressed’ to hear of alleged sexual misconduct by ex-swim coach
- Western States Could Make Billions Selling Renewable Energy, But They’ll Need a Lot More Regional Transmission Lines
- 51-year-old Andy Macdonald puts on Tony Hawk-approved Olympic skateboard showing
- Donald Trump slams Jimmy Kimmel for Oscars flub, seemingly mixing him up with Al Pacino
Ranking
- New Zealand official reverses visa refusal for US conservative influencer Candace Owens
- Dawn Staley shares Beyoncé letter to South Carolina basketball after national championship
- Charges dropped against suspect in 2016 cold case slaying of Tulane graduate
- Off the Grid: Sally breaks down USA TODAY's daily crossword puzzle, Firecrackers
- 51-year-old Andy Macdonald puts on Tony Hawk-approved Olympic skateboard showing
- 'Bachelor' stars react to 'Golden Bachelor' divorce: 'Just two stubborn old people'
- Florida’s Bob Graham dead at 87: A leader who looked beyond politics, served ordinary folks
- Blue Eyeshadow Is Having A Moment - These Are the Best Products You Need To Rock The Look
Recommendation
Illinois Gov. Pritzker calls for sheriff to resign after Sonya Massey shooting
US probe of Hondas that can activate emergency braking for no reason moves closer to a recall
Climate change concerns grow, but few think Biden’s climate law will help, AP-NORC poll finds
California sets long-awaited drinking water limit for ‘Erin Brockovich’ contaminant
Connie Chiume, Black Panther Actress, Dead at 72: Lupita Nyong'o and More Pay Tribute
Athletes beware: Jontay Porter NBA betting scheme is a lesson in stupidity
Charli XCX, Troye Sivan announce joint Sweat concert tour: How to get tickets
Escaping Sudan's yearlong civil war was just the first hurdle to this American family's dream come true